Love is in the air, and so is the aroma of delicious food! Valentine’s Day is the perfect excuse to treat your special someone to a romantic dinner. If you’re in Plymouth, Michigan, you’re in luck—this town is brimming with culinary spots that will make your evening unforgettable. Whether you’re into Italian classics, seafood delights, or a cozy pizza night with a twist, we’ve got you covered. Oh, and don’t forget to check out our full Valentine’s Day Guide 2025 for more date-night ideas!
Nico & Vali Italian Eatery: Romance the Italian Way
If your love language involves pasta and wine, Nico & Vali is calling your name. This family-owned eatery serves up authentic Italian dishes that feel like a warm hug from Nonna herself. Their menu focuses on fresh ingredients, with meats sourced from Michigan farms and wild-caught fish when available.
Menu Highlights:
- Pasta Carbonara: Creamy, dreamy, and packed with flavor.
- Chicken Marsala: Tender chicken with a rich mushroom and Marsala wine sauce.
- Tiramisu: End the night on a sweet note with this classic dessert.
Location & Hours:
- Address: 744 Wing Street, Plymouth, MI 48170
- Hours: Monday–Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM; Closed Sundays
Whether you dine in or grab takeout for a cozy night at home, Nico & Vali ensures your Valentine’s dinner is nothing short of spectacular.
The Sardine Room: Seafood Lovers Unite
For those who prefer their romance served with oysters and lobster claws, The Sardine Room is your go-to spot. Located right across from Kellogg Park in downtown Plymouth, this chic yet relaxed restaurant offers a seafood-centric menu that’s perfect for impressing your date.
Valentine’s Specials (Pre-Order by February 11):
- Cupid Snack Box ($24): A heart-shaped box filled with prosciutto, salami, cheeses, nuts, fruit, crackers, and more—perfect for sharing.
- Petite Platter Royale ($50): A seafood lover’s dream featuring oysters on the half shell, shrimp, lobster claws, and snow crab claws.
- Surf & Turf ($110): Filet mignon paired with lobster risotto plus all the romantic trimmings.
- Pizza My Heart ($70): A heart-shaped pizza with a side of prosecco and chocolate bonbons.
Location & Hours:
- Address: 340 S Main Street, Plymouth, MI 48170
- Hours: Tuesday–Sunday: 4 PM–10 PM; Closed Mondays
Pro tip: Their Valentine’s specials are available for pre-order only (no substitutions), so plan ahead!
Compari’s on the Park: Cozy Italian Comfort
If you’re looking for an inviting atmosphere with food that feels like it was made just for you, Compari’s on the Park delivers. Known for its award-winning brick oven pizzas and hearty Italian entrees, this spot strikes the perfect balance between casual and romantic.
Menu Highlights:
- Brick Oven Pizza: Made from scratch daily—try their Margherita or Meat Lover’s options.
- Eggplant Parmesan: Crispy on the outside, tender on the inside.
- Wine Pairings: Choose from their impressive selection of domestic and imported wines.
Location & Hours:
- Address: 350 S Main Street, Plymouth, MI 48170
- Hours:
- Monday–Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM
- Thursday–Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM
- Sunday: 2 PM–9 PM
With both indoor dining and carryout options available, Compari’s makes it easy to celebrate love your way. No matter which restaurant you choose in Plymouth this Valentine’s Day, you’re guaranteed a night filled with great food and even better company. Make your reservations early—tables tend to fill up faster than chocolate disappears from a heart-shaped box!
Sources: comparisdining.com, nicoandvali.com, thesardineroom.com
Header Image Source: Louis Hansel on Unsplash
